Why Do You Care? You’re Not Even A Member of That Community!

Have you ever been told not to be so sensitive or to stop standing up for others—especially if they are not present? If you have, this post is dedicated to you. Identifying with or being part of a group that is being disparaged or stereotyped is not a requirement or prerequisite to speak up about disrespectful or toxic commentary.
If stereotypical or derogatory statements are being made about a person or a group of people, especially those not present at the time, would you remain silent or speak up and let others in the room know that these statements are derogatory and stereotypical? Yes, speaking up on behalf of others, whether they are present or not, is still conventionally considered the correct thing to do, but the stakes can also escalate to rage and in some cases violence depending on the parties involved. There are several ways to convey your disappointment in discussions that make generalizations about others without compromising your emotional well-being or physical safety.
My first recommendation is to avoid berating the person who made the statement. Once the person feels they’re being targeted, they are less likely to receive your feedback and will probably shut down any constructive dialogue or, worse, escalate tensions. Civilly let the person know that you disagree with their characterization of an entire group of people and would appreciate it if the person did not use absolutes to depict individuals or communities.
Also, try to avoid engaging in "Google Wars" of pulling up statistics on your phone to obliterate the person’s assertions. Scoring intellectual or factual points may make for great viral moments on a virtual discussion panel, but it will do little in an in-person conversation to promote constructive discourse. Calmly voicing that your experience has been very different than what the other person has mentioned does not diminish their perception, but it does provide you with an opportunity to share your experience. When juxtaposed, this clearly provides an alternate view that the aforementioned group is not monolithic or homogeneous, and is not lacking in diversity.
You may be confronted with the question of why you are so passionate about standing up for a demographic you seemingly don’t belong to or have no apparent ties to. Depending on your situation, you could respond that you may not have any direct affiliations with the group being spoken about, but you value the diversity across all groups, refrain from generalizing, and trust others would do the same for you. Another response could be that you have friends and extended family members represented in those demographics, and despite not immediately identifying within those communities, you are an ally and advocate.
There is a more direct response that has the potential to promote reflection, retreat, or escalation. As always, know how to correctly read the room. You could ask the person how they would feel if someone generalized communities they identified with. Hopefully, the person will pause and be receptive to understanding the dynamics of stereotyping, and reconsider using it or not raising concerns when they are in the presence of others voicing such generalized narratives.
It’s time for another moment of parental wisdom. My mother firmly believed that it is easier to generalize about anything or anyone, but it takes courage and intellectual curiosity to take the time to get to know the individual or situation and avoid the distraction of cacophony. I still make those words a part of my daily practice. It is impossible to directly identify with every person on the planet, but my empathy, intellectual curiosity, and desire to know the individual versus the sensationalized headlines or hyped out-of-context snapshots provides me with the opportunity each day to meet people as they are in lieu of how they may be randomly characterized. Headlines may go viral, but genuine connections can last a lifetime. Let’s aim for seeing the totality and complexity of the individual rather than the mass narrative that deemphasizes nuance and distinction. Consider caring about what is being said regardless of whether you are a member of that specific community or demographic being scrutinized. Hopefully, others will be as mindful when you are the topic of discussion. Paying it forward still has relevance for us all.




Comments